Skip to content

Conversation

@emreakay
Copy link
Contributor

  • Test @aauth and @endaauth directive compilation
  • Test permission checking behavior
  • Test support for single/double quotes and variables
  • Test nested directives and multiple blocks
  • Test HTML content rendering with permissions

Resolves #31

- Test @aauth and @endaauth directive compilation
- Test permission checking behavior
- Test support for single/double quotes and variables
- Test nested directives and multiple blocks
- Test HTML content rendering with permissions

Resolves #31

Co-authored-by: EA <emreakay@users.noreply.github.com>
@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Dec 20, 2025

PR Review: Add comprehensive unit tests for Blade directives

Thank you for this comprehensive test suite for the Blade directives! This PR addresses issue #31 and provides solid coverage for the @aauth and @endaauth directives.

✅ Strengths

  1. Comprehensive Coverage: The test suite covers all major use cases including directive compilation, permission checking, support for quotes/variables, nested directives, and HTML content rendering.

  2. Good Test Structure: Tests follow a clear pattern and use Pest's expressive syntax effectively.

  3. Real-World Scenarios: Testing with actual HTML content and multiple blocks reflects real usage patterns.

🔍 Critical Issue: Security Vulnerability with eval()

Severity: High - Lines 38-41, 51-54, 113-115, 134-137

The tests use eval() to execute compiled Blade templates. This is a significant security risk and is generally discouraged in PHP.

Recommendation: Use Laravel's built-in Blade::render() method instead of compiling and using eval(). This is safer, cleaner, and more maintainable.

🔍 Issue: Database Overhead

Severity: Medium

Every test runs migrate:fresh and seeds the database in beforeEach (executed 10 times). Compilation tests don't need database setup at all, making tests unnecessarily slow.

Recommendation: Split into compilation tests (no DB) and rendering tests (with DB), or use database transactions instead of migrate:fresh.

🔍 Issue: Hardcoded User/Role IDs

Severity: Low - Lines 13-18

Tests hardcode User::find(1) and role ID 3, making them fragile if the seeder changes.

Recommendation: Use named lookups like Role::whereName('Organization Role 1')->first() to match patterns in RolePermissionServiceTest.php.

📊 Test Coverage

Current: Good foundation covering compilation, rendering, quotes, variables, nesting, and HTML content.

Missing: Error handling, edge cases (empty strings, whitespace), and XSS testing.

Overall Assessment

This is a solid test suite with good coverage. Main concerns are the eval() security risk and performance overhead. Once addressed, this will be an excellent addition.

Recommendation: Request changes to address eval() usage and database overhead before merging.

@emreakay emreakay merged commit 22ea8fa into main Dec 20, 2025
16 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Blade Directive Unit tests

2 participants